Lithuania, Quotation, Quotation

From
Revision as of 11:06, 27 January 2023 by Caterinasganga f2e342mk (talk | contribs) (Created page with "{{Provision |Legal provision=Article 21 of the Law of 18 May 1999 n. VIII-1185 Article 58(1)(14) of the Law of 18 May 1999 n. VIII-1185 |Notes on Legal provision=The excepti...")
(diff) ← Older revision | Latest revision (diff) | Newer revision → (diff)
Jump to: navigation, search
Flexibility Category Quotation
Flexibility Subcategory Quotation
Country Lithuania
Legal provision Article 21 of the Law of 18 May 1999 n. VIII-1185

Article 58(1)(14) of the Law of 18 May 1999 n. VIII-1185

Notes on Legal provision The exception has been broadened by the Law n. XIV-970 of 24 March 2022 to cover online quotations, as a consequence of the transposition of Article 17(7) of the CDSM Directive.
Entry into force 2022
Notes on Entry into force
Related EU provision Article 5(3)(d) InfoSoc
Notes on Related EU provision
Legal text in English Article 21

It is permitted to reproduce, publish and publicly announce (among other things, to make publicly available via computer networks (Internet)) without the permission of the author of the work or another subject of the copyright of this work and without royalties, but with indication, if possible, of the source used and the name of the author, a small part of a legally published or publicly published work, whether in the original language or translated into another language, as a quotation (for the purposes of criticism or review) in another work, provided that such use is fair and does not exceed the extent necessary for the purpose of the quotation.

Article 58(1)(14) The use of a performance, phonogram, electronic press release, recording of an audiovisual work (film) and the broadcast of a broadcasting organization or their recordings is permitted without the permission of the subjects of related rights and without remuneration, but with the indication, if possible, of the source used and the name of the artist: (…)

14) for the purposes of citation (criticism or review) to reproduce and publicly announce (among other things, make publicly available via computer networks (on the Internet)) a small part of the legally published or publicly announced object of related rights in another object of copyright or related rights, if such use is fair and does not exceed the extent necessary for the purpose of the citation; (...). 

3. Limitations of related rights specified in paragraph 1 of this Article must not conflict with a normal exploitation of the objects of the said rights and must not unreasonably prejudice the legitimate interests of performers, producers of phonograms, producers of the first fixation of an audiovisual work or broadcasting organisations.

Notes on Legal text in English Unofficial translation
Beneficiaries Users (in general)
Notes on Beneficiaries
Beneficiaries Score
Subject-matter Works

Performances Phonograms Cinematographic works Broadcasts

Notes on Subject-matter This exception applies to legally published works. Pursuant to Article 58(1)(14) of the Act, this exception extends to the objects of related rights.
Subject-matter Score
Rights or uses covered Reproduction

Making available to the public Translation

Notes on Rights or uses covered
Rights or uses covered Score
Purpose of the use Criticism or review
Notes on Purpose of the use
Purpose of the use Score
Remuneration? Yes
Notes on Remuneration?
Remuneration Score
Attribution? Yes
Notes on Attribution?
Attribution Score
Other conditions of applicability Purpose-based limitations

Compliance with fair practices Extent limited to necessity Three-step-test (explicit mention) Others

Notes on Other conditions of applicability Others: The exception covers only the use of small parts of the works.

Three-step-test: Article 19(1) of the Act, applicable to all exceptions and limitations to copyright, requires compliance with the three-step-test for uses of works, while Article 58(3) of the Act requires the same for exceptions and limitations to related rights.

Other conditions of applicability Score
Case law
Notes on Case law
Related case law Civil Case No 3K-3-270-687/2017, 15 June 2017.

Civil Case No e3K-3-513-916/2016, 14 December 2016.

Notes on Related case law In a case (2017) concerning the distribution of activity books reproducing other original textbooks, the Supreme Court of Lithuania considered the purpose and amount taken from the original work to conclude that the quotation at issue was not lawful because it essentially reproduced the original work. This finding was also supported by the absence of any mention of the source quoted.

In a case related to the quotation of an online news article in another media (2016) the Supreme Court of Lithuania held that, when assessing the lawfulness of a quotation, it shall be considered whether a prima facie unlawful citation, namely a quote which does not meet the requirements laid down in Article 21 LiCA, refers to facts or current events in the public domain. The Court expressed the need to ensure a proper balance between rightholders of protected works and the interest of users’ with regard to information that cannot be monopolized.

Type of remuneration
Notes on Type of remuneration
Statutory reference
Notes on Statutory reference
Special characteristics of the scheme
Notes on Special characteristics of the scheme
Specificities in implementation