Belgium, Quotation, Quotation

From
Jump to: navigation, search
Flexibility Category Quotation
Flexibility Subcategory Quotation
Country Belgium
Legal provision Article XI.189, § 1er CDE

Article XI.217, 1° CDE

Notes on Legal provision
Entry into force 1886, 1994, 2015
"4,2015" can not be assigned to a declared number type with value 1886199.
Notes on Entry into force
Related EU provision Article 5(3)(d) InfoSoc
Notes on Related EU provision
Legal text in English Art. XI.189. § 1. Quotations, taken from a lawfully published work, made for the purpose of criticism, polemic, or review, in accordance with the honest practices of the profession and to the extent justified by the purpose, do not infringe copyright.

The quotations referred to in the previous paragraph must mention the source and the name of the author, unless this is impossible. (...)

Art. XI.217. Articles XI.205 (reproduction of performances), XI.209 (reproduction of phonograms and cinematographic works), XI.213 (use of performances and phonograms) and XI.215 (reproduction, making available and communication to the public of broadcasts) shall not apply where the acts referred to in those provisions are performed for the following purposes: 1° quotations taken from a performance, carried out for the purpose of criticism, polemic or review, in accordance with the honest practices of the profession and to the extent justified by the aim pursued; (...).

Notes on Legal text in English
Beneficiaries Not specified.
Notes on Beneficiaries
Beneficiaries Score
Subject-matter Works

Performances

Notes on Subject-matter Other subject matters protected by related rights are excluded from the scope of this provision.
Subject-matter Score
Rights or uses covered Reproduction
Notes on Rights or uses covered
Rights or uses covered Score
Purpose of the use Criticism or review
Notes on Purpose of the use
Purpose of the use Score
Remuneration? Yes
Notes on Remuneration?
Remuneration Score
Attribution? Yes
Notes on Attribution?
Attribution Score
Other conditions of applicability Purpose-based limitations

Extent limited to necessity Compliance with fair practices Three-step-test (explicit mention)

Notes on Other conditions of applicability Article XI.192/3 CDE applies the three-step-test to the exceptions and limitations to copyright envisioned within CDE, whereas Article XI.218/3 CDE does the same for the objects of related rights (i.e., performances, phonograms, first fixations of films, and broadcasts) as well as for orphan works.
Other conditions of applicability Score
Case law
Notes on Case law
Related case law Brussels Court of Appeal, 14 October 2003 (Ars Antiques Auctions v Sabam), Auteurs & Media, 2004/1, pp. 40-41.

Brussels Court of Appeal, 3 May 2005 (Sofam v Vlaamse Media), 3 May 2005, Auteurs & Media, 2005/5, pp. 419-424. Antwerpen Court of Appeal, 25 June 2007 (M. Mallant e.a.v Standaard Uitgeverij), Auteurs & Media, 2007/5, pp. 461-466. Brussels Court of Appeal, 5 May 2011 (Google v Copiepresse e.a.), Auteurs & Media, 2012, p. 202. Liege Court of Appeal, 16 May 2013 (Primento v L.B. and Edition ETC, Inc.), Auteurs et Media, 2013/5, p. 377. President of Brussels Commercial Court, 9 February 2017 (La Libre Match v Sud Presse), Auteurs & Media, 2016/4, p. 342. President of Liege Commercial Court, 19 February 2019 (RTBF & Sudpresse v P.T.), Auteurs & Media, 2018-2019/3, pp. 369-378.

Notes on Related case law
Type of remuneration
Notes on Type of remuneration
Statutory reference
Notes on Statutory reference
Special characteristics of the scheme
Notes on Special characteristics of the scheme
Specificities in implementation