Germany, Quotation, Quotation
| Flexibility Category | Quotation |
|---|---|
| Flexibility Subcategory | Quotation |
| Country | Germany |
| Legal provision | Section 51 UrhG |
| Notes on Legal provision | |
| Entry into force | 2007 |
| Notes on Entry into force | |
| Related EU provision | Article 5(3)(d) InfoSoc |
| Notes on Related EU provision | |
| Legal text in English | Section 51
Quotations It is permitted to reproduce, distribute and communicate to the public a published work for the purpose of quotation insofar as such use is justified to that extent by the particular purpose. This is, in particular, permitted where 1. subsequent to publication individual works are included in an independent scientific work for the purpose of explaining its content, 2. subsequent to publication passages from a work are quoted in an independent literary work, 3. individual passages from a released musical work are quoted in an independent musical work. The authorisation to quote under sentences 1 and 2 includes the use of an illustration or other reproduction of the cited work, even if this is itself protected by copyright or a related right. |
| Notes on Legal text in English | The legal text in English provided herein relies on the official translation of the German Act on Copyright and Related Rights translated by Ute Reusch and available on the official website of the Federal Ministry of Justice. |
| Beneficiaries | Not specified. |
| Notes on Beneficiaries | |
| Beneficiaries Score | |
| Subject-matter | Works
Performances Phonograms Broadcasts |
| Notes on Subject-matter | While this provision already refers to works protected by copyright and objects of related rights; the scope of the exceptions and limitations encompassed within Division 6 (Sections 44a-63a UrhG), including the one enshrined in this provision, are extended to performances by Section 83 UrhG, to phonograms by Section 85(4) UrhG, and to broadcasts by Section 87(4) UrhG. |
| Subject-matter Score | |
| Rights or uses covered | Reproduction
Distribution Communication to the public |
| Notes on Rights or uses covered | |
| Rights or uses covered Score | |
| Purpose of the use | Quotation |
| Notes on Purpose of the use | |
| Purpose of the use Score | |
| Remuneration? | Yes |
| Notes on Remuneration? | |
| Remuneration Score | |
| Attribution? | Yes |
| Notes on Attribution? | According to Section 63 UrhG, it is required to mention the source of the subject matter as well as the name of the author, if this does not prove impossible. |
| Attribution Score | |
| Other conditions of applicability | Purpose-based limitations
Extent limited to necessity |
| Notes on Other conditions of applicability | This provision requires compliance neither with fair practices nor with the three-step-test. |
| Other conditions of applicability Score | |
| Case law | |
| Notes on Case law | |
| Related case law | BGH, 1.6.2017 – I ZR 139/15 – Afghanistan Papiere.
BGH, 30.04.2020 - I ZR 139/15 – Afghanistan Papiere II. BGH, 27.7.2017 – I ZR 228/15 – Reformistischer Aufbruch. BGH, 30.04.2020 – I ZR 228/15 – Reformistischer Aufbruch II. BGH, 30.04.2020 - I ZR 115/16 – Metall auf Metall IV. BGH, 17.12.2015 – I ZR 69/14 – Exklusivinterview. BGH, 30.11.2011 – I ZR 212/10 – Blühende Landschaften. |
| Notes on Related case law | |
| Type of remuneration | |
| Notes on Type of remuneration | |
| Statutory reference | |
| Notes on Statutory reference | |
| Special characteristics of the scheme | |
| Notes on Special characteristics of the scheme | |
| Specificities in implementation |