Luxembourg, Quotation, Quotation 1

From
Jump to: navigation, search
Flexibility Category Quotation
Flexibility Subcategory Quotation
Country Luxembourg
Legal provision Article 70bis(8) of the Law of 18 April 2001 on Copyright, Related rights and Databases
Notes on Legal provision Law n. 158 of 5 April 2022, implementing the CDSM Directive, has introduced an explicit reference to quotation, parody, caricature and pastiche as mandatory exception for users/uploaders of protected works on OCSSPs, transposing verbatim Article 17(7) CDSM.
Entry into force 2022
Notes on Entry into force
Related EU provision Article 17(7) CDSM
Notes on Related EU provision
Legal text in English Article 70bis

(...) (8) Cooperation between providers of online content sharing services and rightholders should not result in preventing the making available of works or other subject-matter uploaded by users which do not infringe copyright and related rights, including where such works or other subject-matter are covered by an exception or limitation.

Users may avail themselves of any of the following existing exceptions or limitations when uploading and making available user-generated content on online content sharing services: 1° quotation, criticism, review; (...).

Notes on Legal text in English Unofficial translation
Beneficiaries Users (in general)
Notes on Beneficiaries
Beneficiaries Score
Subject-matter Works or other subject matters
Notes on Subject-matter
Subject-matter Score
Rights or uses covered Not specified.
Notes on Rights or uses covered
Rights or uses covered Score
Purpose of the use Criticism or review
Notes on Purpose of the use
Purpose of the use Score
Remuneration? Yes
Notes on Remuneration?
Remuneration Score
Attribution? Yes
Notes on Attribution?
Attribution Score
Other conditions of applicability Purpose-based limitations
Notes on Other conditions of applicability Purpose-based limitations: The exception applies when users upload and make available user generated content on online content sharing services.

Three-step-test: This provision does not require compliance with the three-step test. However, the provision expressly indicate that "users may avail from the existing exceptions", which requires compliance with the three-step-test, as per Articles 10 and 46, last part.

Other conditions of applicability Score
Case law
Notes on Case law
Related case law n/a
Notes on Related case law
Type of remuneration
Notes on Type of remuneration
Statutory reference
Notes on Statutory reference
Special characteristics of the scheme
Notes on Special characteristics of the scheme
Specificities in implementation